How do bees become Africanized?
There are many different varieties of honeybees (Apis mellefera), and any of them can hybridize if they are put together. While there are native bees in the Americas, the honeybees that are kept for pollination and honey production are all imported. The most common variety is the European honeybee. These bees are pretty hardy, but they are best adapted to cooler climates that one finds in the tropics. Their honey production and the stability of the hives is lower in the hotter areas of the Americas.
In the 1950s, a biologist named Warwick E. Kerr, tired of merely being a guy with a cool name, decided he would interbreed bees from Africa that were adapted to a hot climate with honey-producing European bees. He was working in Brazil, and he figured that he could benefit from the combined traits of these two bees: the large capacity for creating honey of the European bees, and the heat tolerance of the African bees.
The bees that Kerr created were good at tolerating heat. They were also more aggressive than European honeybees, more likely to swarm, and more persistent in pursuing invaders. In fact, they can chase an animal a quarter of a mile. This is pretty good stamina (although you can still outrun bees if you keep it up for long enough - click here if you don't believe me). Kerr managed these hives as an experiment, and he did not intend for them to be set free in the wild. He put a special type of screen on the hives called "queen excluders" on the hives. These are meant to allow the worker bees to enter and leave the hives, but hold the queens and drones - who are larger - in the hive. This will keep the hives intact and prevent swarming. Somebody removed the excluders, and 26 colonies swarmed and started to spread.
Since the bees were quite suited to the tropical heat of Brazil, they started to spread. Due to their aggressiveness, people became afraid and started calling the Africanized honey bees "killer bees." There was a lot of sensationalism about the possible spread of Africanized bees, including a popular movie in 1974 called Killer Bees. It is still common to hear people use the term "killer bees," although most bee experts object to the term. Africanized bees are more aggressive than regular honey bees, but bees who do not feel threatened are not a danger to anybody. There are definitely precautions you should take around bees - particularly near their hives - but you have probably seen hundreds of Africanized bees without incident.
Africanized bees did spread, and they are quite common in the southern United States. Exactly how common they are is a matter of some debate. A recent study in California showed that among managed colonies, 13% have DNA of African bees, while the percentage of non-managed bees who are at least partially Africanized is over 60%. Thorough research has not been done on bees in Arizona, but most bee experts believe the percentage will prove to be higher here.
Africanized bees have likely reached their northernmost boundary by now. They thrive in places with mild winter temperatures because they do not store enough food to make it through a long, cold winter. In places like Arizona, though, it is likely that bees will increasingly show Africanized traits because they are so suited to hot climates.
Bees become increasingly Africanized in three different ways:
1. Existing hives will swarm and form new colonies;
2. Their drones will interbreed with European honeybee queens;
3. and they will take over existing honeybee hives.
This last method is fascinating, and it was only recently discovered. Africanized bees can go into an existing colony, kill their queen, and replace her with one of their own queens.
Each colony of bees has its own personality, and there are Africanized colonies that are relatively docile. Since Africanized bees are so well adapted to our environment, maybe the best way to deal with their increase is to replace hostile queens with less aggressive ones. The colony will quickly take on the personality of their new queen.
Tuesday, June 14, 2016
Friday, June 10, 2016
Favorite Color
What's your favorite color?
There were a lot of questions like this. Even though I dress in a drab manner, I love colors. My favorites are blue, green, and purple.
There were a lot of questions like this. Even though I dress in a drab manner, I love colors. My favorites are blue, green, and purple.
Tutankhamun's Tomb
Do you have an update on the secret chambers in Tutankhamun's tomb?
Yes, I do. A couple of students asked about this, and it is gratifying that they care about these historical mysteries.
It has long been known that many of the grave goods were not originally crafted for Tut, but were re-purposed goods made for someone else. Nicholas Reeves, a highly-regarded Egyptologist from the University of Arizona, claims that most of the grave goods were originally for a mysterious female pharaoh known as "Neferneferuaten," who was probably Nefertiti. The most famous artifact from the tomb, Tut's death mask, was clearly retrofitted by cutting the face off and replacing it with Tut's face. Reeves found evidence that there was originally an inscription inside identifying Nefertiti as the owner; that inscription was scratched out and replaced with Tut's name.
Other people have pointed out that Tut's tomb itself seems to have originally been made for someone other than Tut. They had to cut into the walls to make room for the sarcophagus, and the shape of the tomb is more typical of a queen's tomb than a king's. Since we haven't located Nefertiti's tomb, some people speculate that Tut's tomb was originally meant for her, and that she may have been hastily buried somewhere else (or some other random thing happened to her mummy).
Reeves developed a theory that the tomb is actually Nefertiti's, and that she is not buried elsewhere - but she is still inside that tomb! He looked carefully at images of the walls and noticed evidence that there might be hidden chambers behind a wall in the same room where Tut's sarcophagus was. He started to believe that the ancient Egyptians took an existing tomb and built walls to retrofit it into a new tomb for Tut.
Evidence to support Reeves' theory mounted earlier this year when Japanese radar expert Hirokatsu Watanabe used ground-penetrating radar to show that there may be hidden chambers. Watanabe said the images shows the presence of metals and organic material within the chambers, which obviously would be consistent with a hidden tomb.
Some Egyptian tourism officials were excited about these findings, since visits to Egypt have dropped off as a result of political turmoil. Perhaps a major discovery would be able to bring people back.
Other experts were not convinced. Former Egypt Antiquities Minister Zahi Hawass was skeptical of the claims, and other radar experts interpreted Watanabe's scans as being inconclusive. In March and April of this month there was a large, well-coordinated effort to duplicate Watanabe's results.
Egyptian officials stalled on issuing the results, and they have been reticent to publicize them, mainly because the more detailed scans indicate that there are no hidden chambers.
As for me, I still hope they find something, but I doubt it. I am especially disappointed in further research into Watanabe's scans. He enthusiastically claimed that there almost certainly were hidden chambers, although most experts say that his scans don't show any evidence. Watanabe has an eccentric way of interpreting results that he refuses to explain to anybody. It seems Watanabe may have been using this as a means of self-promotion and not as a serious attempt to further scientific inquiry.
Yes, I do. A couple of students asked about this, and it is gratifying that they care about these historical mysteries.
It has long been known that many of the grave goods were not originally crafted for Tut, but were re-purposed goods made for someone else. Nicholas Reeves, a highly-regarded Egyptologist from the University of Arizona, claims that most of the grave goods were originally for a mysterious female pharaoh known as "Neferneferuaten," who was probably Nefertiti. The most famous artifact from the tomb, Tut's death mask, was clearly retrofitted by cutting the face off and replacing it with Tut's face. Reeves found evidence that there was originally an inscription inside identifying Nefertiti as the owner; that inscription was scratched out and replaced with Tut's name.
Other people have pointed out that Tut's tomb itself seems to have originally been made for someone other than Tut. They had to cut into the walls to make room for the sarcophagus, and the shape of the tomb is more typical of a queen's tomb than a king's. Since we haven't located Nefertiti's tomb, some people speculate that Tut's tomb was originally meant for her, and that she may have been hastily buried somewhere else (or some other random thing happened to her mummy).
Reeves developed a theory that the tomb is actually Nefertiti's, and that she is not buried elsewhere - but she is still inside that tomb! He looked carefully at images of the walls and noticed evidence that there might be hidden chambers behind a wall in the same room where Tut's sarcophagus was. He started to believe that the ancient Egyptians took an existing tomb and built walls to retrofit it into a new tomb for Tut.
Evidence to support Reeves' theory mounted earlier this year when Japanese radar expert Hirokatsu Watanabe used ground-penetrating radar to show that there may be hidden chambers. Watanabe said the images shows the presence of metals and organic material within the chambers, which obviously would be consistent with a hidden tomb.
Some Egyptian tourism officials were excited about these findings, since visits to Egypt have dropped off as a result of political turmoil. Perhaps a major discovery would be able to bring people back.
Other experts were not convinced. Former Egypt Antiquities Minister Zahi Hawass was skeptical of the claims, and other radar experts interpreted Watanabe's scans as being inconclusive. In March and April of this month there was a large, well-coordinated effort to duplicate Watanabe's results.
Egyptian officials stalled on issuing the results, and they have been reticent to publicize them, mainly because the more detailed scans indicate that there are no hidden chambers.
As for me, I still hope they find something, but I doubt it. I am especially disappointed in further research into Watanabe's scans. He enthusiastically claimed that there almost certainly were hidden chambers, although most experts say that his scans don't show any evidence. Watanabe has an eccentric way of interpreting results that he refuses to explain to anybody. It seems Watanabe may have been using this as a means of self-promotion and not as a serious attempt to further scientific inquiry.
Thursday, June 9, 2016
21
Why is the drinking age 21? Where did the 21 come from? It seems like an arbitrary age.
In 1984, Ronald Reagan signed the National Minimum Drinking Age into law. This law told the states that if they did not change the drinking age to 21 they would lose 10% of their federal highway funding. Eventually all the states fell into line, and this led to a reduction in the number of drunken-driving deaths, so it seems the law had a good effect. I know you may be wondering why a person who found this sneaky way of forcing states into changing their laws to align with federal policies - even though the 21st amendment defers the power to regulate alcohol to the states - is considered to be the hero of limiting federal control over the states, but I don't want to argue about it.
The question here is how did 21 come to be seen as the age of majority in this case. Why not 20 or 22? The absolute origin of 21 as a magic age is lost to antiquity, but it is clear that it came to our country from English Common Law, which was once the law of land here in the states, where our legal heritage originates with the original 13 colonies, which were all bound by British law.
You may ask, What is English Common Law? A quick answer two this is that the British do not have a constitution like we have: a document that was written down and you can go and read. Their law consists of statutes that have been passed by kings and parliaments throughout history (known as "statute law"), and various legal judgments and conventions (known as "common law").
English common law gave people increasing responsibility as they aged. Common law took into account the fact that girls mature more quickly than boys, so they do not always get rights at the same age. Men began to gain rights at the age of 14, while girls would begin at 12. For example, a man could sign a contract at 14, but could choose not to ratify it at 21, even though an adult who entered a contract with a minor was bound to follow it. It raises the question of why anybody would enter a contract with a child since the child could so easily abrogate it, but that is the law. A man could marry without parental consent at 21. An interesting rundown of various rights by age can be found here; I can't vouch for its accuracy, but it is pretty interesting.
Outside of England and its colonies, the age of 21 doesn't have the magic power as it has here. There are a handful of countries that have a minimum drinking age of 21. All of these countries are either former British colonies, Islamic countries who have additional restrictions concerning who can purchase alcohol, Pacific islands that have a history of close ties with the United States. Taking a world-wide perspective, a drinking age of 21 is very rare. 18 is the most common, although some places have 19 or 20. Because of our success in reducing accidents by raising the drinking the age, there have been attempts in places like New Zealand, Australia, and the Philippines to increase the drinking age, but we are still relative outliers.
An interesting sidenote is that the original Selective Service Act of 1917 required men to register at 21. The age was lowered to 18 in 1918. Since some people object to men being required to register at 18 even though they are not allowed to drink until 21, maybe Selective Service should be changed back.
In 1984, Ronald Reagan signed the National Minimum Drinking Age into law. This law told the states that if they did not change the drinking age to 21 they would lose 10% of their federal highway funding. Eventually all the states fell into line, and this led to a reduction in the number of drunken-driving deaths, so it seems the law had a good effect. I know you may be wondering why a person who found this sneaky way of forcing states into changing their laws to align with federal policies - even though the 21st amendment defers the power to regulate alcohol to the states - is considered to be the hero of limiting federal control over the states, but I don't want to argue about it.
The question here is how did 21 come to be seen as the age of majority in this case. Why not 20 or 22? The absolute origin of 21 as a magic age is lost to antiquity, but it is clear that it came to our country from English Common Law, which was once the law of land here in the states, where our legal heritage originates with the original 13 colonies, which were all bound by British law.
You may ask, What is English Common Law? A quick answer two this is that the British do not have a constitution like we have: a document that was written down and you can go and read. Their law consists of statutes that have been passed by kings and parliaments throughout history (known as "statute law"), and various legal judgments and conventions (known as "common law").
English common law gave people increasing responsibility as they aged. Common law took into account the fact that girls mature more quickly than boys, so they do not always get rights at the same age. Men began to gain rights at the age of 14, while girls would begin at 12. For example, a man could sign a contract at 14, but could choose not to ratify it at 21, even though an adult who entered a contract with a minor was bound to follow it. It raises the question of why anybody would enter a contract with a child since the child could so easily abrogate it, but that is the law. A man could marry without parental consent at 21. An interesting rundown of various rights by age can be found here; I can't vouch for its accuracy, but it is pretty interesting.
Outside of England and its colonies, the age of 21 doesn't have the magic power as it has here. There are a handful of countries that have a minimum drinking age of 21. All of these countries are either former British colonies, Islamic countries who have additional restrictions concerning who can purchase alcohol, Pacific islands that have a history of close ties with the United States. Taking a world-wide perspective, a drinking age of 21 is very rare. 18 is the most common, although some places have 19 or 20. Because of our success in reducing accidents by raising the drinking the age, there have been attempts in places like New Zealand, Australia, and the Philippines to increase the drinking age, but we are still relative outliers.
An interesting sidenote is that the original Selective Service Act of 1917 required men to register at 21. The age was lowered to 18 in 1918. Since some people object to men being required to register at 18 even though they are not allowed to drink until 21, maybe Selective Service should be changed back.
Tuesday, June 7, 2016
Allergies
How did ancient people fight off the first allergies?
This is a good question, and there is not much information. In fact, there is not much mention of hay fever type allergies in ancient sources, although ancient people were aware of allergic reactions to animals and foods. According the Psychoneuroimmunology by Robert Ader, the earliest report of an allergic reaction was King Menses of Egypt, who died of a wasp sting some time between 3640 - 3300 BCE. Ader also reports that Britannicus, the son of emperor Claudius, was so allergic to horses that his eyes would swell shut and he couldn't see where he was going. In these cases, the remedy was to avoid horses as much as possible.
Hay fever - which is an allergic reaction to dust, mold, and pollen - was not formally described until 1906. This does not mean these did not exist (although see below), just that it was not recognized as a specific phenomenon. The ancients did know about breathing problems (asthma), and there are numerous treatments mentioned in ancient sources. These fall into two categories - inhaling steam that has been scented with herbs, and taking tea that includes stimulants known to cause bronchodilation (particularly ephedra in China). Both of these methods are somewhat effective.
For a while, I lived in a place called Johnson Mesa, New Mexico. I never figured out what it was, but I was extraordinarily allergic to something there. I read in a book that a common folk remedy for allergies was to take the resinous sap of a plant and paint that inside your nose. Supposedly this remedy went all the way back to Plains Indians. The theory is that the sap causes pollen to stick so you don't inhale it. It did not work so well.
While we find that there are symptoms described in ancient sources that are similar to allergies, it definitely was not very important to them. In fact, research shows that allergies are much more common among industrialized nations, and that they are becoming more and more common as people become increasingly urbanized. The cause for this seems to be related to the reduced incidence of parasites. Our immune system evolved to fight off parasites, and if you do not have parasites it will turn against things like pollens and molds. Allergies are essentially an over-reaction to these relatively harmless irritants. People can reduce their allergies by infecting themselves with parasites. If you are interested in ordering some hookworms, click here. There is an interesting article about parasites and allergies from Smithsonian Magazine that you can read here.
This is a good question, and there is not much information. In fact, there is not much mention of hay fever type allergies in ancient sources, although ancient people were aware of allergic reactions to animals and foods. According the Psychoneuroimmunology by Robert Ader, the earliest report of an allergic reaction was King Menses of Egypt, who died of a wasp sting some time between 3640 - 3300 BCE. Ader also reports that Britannicus, the son of emperor Claudius, was so allergic to horses that his eyes would swell shut and he couldn't see where he was going. In these cases, the remedy was to avoid horses as much as possible.
Hay fever - which is an allergic reaction to dust, mold, and pollen - was not formally described until 1906. This does not mean these did not exist (although see below), just that it was not recognized as a specific phenomenon. The ancients did know about breathing problems (asthma), and there are numerous treatments mentioned in ancient sources. These fall into two categories - inhaling steam that has been scented with herbs, and taking tea that includes stimulants known to cause bronchodilation (particularly ephedra in China). Both of these methods are somewhat effective.
For a while, I lived in a place called Johnson Mesa, New Mexico. I never figured out what it was, but I was extraordinarily allergic to something there. I read in a book that a common folk remedy for allergies was to take the resinous sap of a plant and paint that inside your nose. Supposedly this remedy went all the way back to Plains Indians. The theory is that the sap causes pollen to stick so you don't inhale it. It did not work so well.
While we find that there are symptoms described in ancient sources that are similar to allergies, it definitely was not very important to them. In fact, research shows that allergies are much more common among industrialized nations, and that they are becoming more and more common as people become increasingly urbanized. The cause for this seems to be related to the reduced incidence of parasites. Our immune system evolved to fight off parasites, and if you do not have parasites it will turn against things like pollens and molds. Allergies are essentially an over-reaction to these relatively harmless irritants. People can reduce their allergies by infecting themselves with parasites. If you are interested in ordering some hookworms, click here. There is an interesting article about parasites and allergies from Smithsonian Magazine that you can read here.
Monday, June 6, 2016
Name of the Blog, Antony and Cleopatra
Why did you name your blog Smells Like Pirates? Why? Do you know what pirates smell like? Have you ever been a pirate?
I have never been a pirate, but do have a pretty good guess what pirates smell like, mostly based on how other people smell when they do the sort of work pirates do. As to why I gave the blog this name, I answered that (more-or-less) in the first post, but I will give a little backstory that should make it clearer.
Several years ago I was teaching that class, and during that class we were talking about sewage systems. I don't remember why, but that was a topic of discussion. I pointed out that in places where the sewers depend on gravity to bring the sewer waters to the treatment plant, it is not unusual for a clog to cause the sewage of people living in the hills to flood into the houses of people living in the valleys. Most of the students understood instinctively, but somebody wanted me to draw a picture. I drew a house on a hill and said it was Matthew Padgett's, and a house in the valley and said it was mine. I drew the sewer lines under the house and showed where the clog was. I then said, "At first it is not a big problem, but as the sewage gets more and more backed up it will eventually start to fill up my bathtub and sinks. One day I will come home, open the door, and say 'It smells like Padgett in here.'"
As a result of this story, the phrase "It smells like Padgett" became one of the catchphrases of that class.
When I submitted my proposal to travel to museums to study how pirates are portrayed, I remembered how catchy the phrase about Padgett was, so I just replaced "Padgett" with "pirates." The name does cause some confusion, but it has proven to be rather memorable.
Is the story of the deaths of Antony and Cleopatra in Shakespeare historically accurate?
I think what the student is wanting to know here is related to Cleopatra's motivation in telling Antony that she is dead. In the play Antony and Cleopatra, Antony becomes angry at Cleopatra after he is abandoned by his cavalry. He believes it is a result of Cleopatra betraying him. Cleopatra runs to a mausoleum and locks herself in. There here servant Charmian tells Cleopatra that she should send a servant to tell Antony that she (Cleopatra) is dead, so she does. She then wants the servant to return to tell her how Antony took the news.
The clear implication is that Cleopatra is trying to see if Antony still loves her. She wants to know if he will mourn her or callously claim that he is relieved. Cleopatra's insecurity was previously seen when she was taken aback that Antony did not mourn more passionately for his wife Fulvia; she wonders if he will act the same when she herself dies.
The historical records we have, even those used by Shakespeare, do not make such a clear case for her wanting to test his love. Shakespeare's main source for the play was Plutarch's Life of Antony. Shakespeare's description of the death of Antony is very similar to the one in Plutarch. The main difference is that Plutarch does not make it clear that she is trying to test his love. In fact, Plutarch implies that she sends the message so that Antony, who believes he had been betrayed, will stop pursuing her. In other words, she is lying to him to save her own neck.
I think the notion that Cleopatra wants to see if Antony still loves her is mainly Shakespeare's idea, and I can't find it clearly stated as a motivation in any of the historical documents. On the other hand, it seems at least - which is why that is how I wrote it into the puppet show that I created to review this story.
As an interesting side note, almost all of the people who wrote a summary of the story of Antony and Cleopatra for the final included the detail that Cleopatra did it to test to see if Antony still loved her, even though I barely mentioned it in class. The puppet show seems to have been influential on how my students viewed the historical event. It is always best to look stuff up for yourself, and not to trust a puppet show too much.
I have never been a pirate, but do have a pretty good guess what pirates smell like, mostly based on how other people smell when they do the sort of work pirates do. As to why I gave the blog this name, I answered that (more-or-less) in the first post, but I will give a little backstory that should make it clearer.
Several years ago I was teaching that class, and during that class we were talking about sewage systems. I don't remember why, but that was a topic of discussion. I pointed out that in places where the sewers depend on gravity to bring the sewer waters to the treatment plant, it is not unusual for a clog to cause the sewage of people living in the hills to flood into the houses of people living in the valleys. Most of the students understood instinctively, but somebody wanted me to draw a picture. I drew a house on a hill and said it was Matthew Padgett's, and a house in the valley and said it was mine. I drew the sewer lines under the house and showed where the clog was. I then said, "At first it is not a big problem, but as the sewage gets more and more backed up it will eventually start to fill up my bathtub and sinks. One day I will come home, open the door, and say 'It smells like Padgett in here.'"
As a result of this story, the phrase "It smells like Padgett" became one of the catchphrases of that class.
When I submitted my proposal to travel to museums to study how pirates are portrayed, I remembered how catchy the phrase about Padgett was, so I just replaced "Padgett" with "pirates." The name does cause some confusion, but it has proven to be rather memorable.
Is the story of the deaths of Antony and Cleopatra in Shakespeare historically accurate?
I think what the student is wanting to know here is related to Cleopatra's motivation in telling Antony that she is dead. In the play Antony and Cleopatra, Antony becomes angry at Cleopatra after he is abandoned by his cavalry. He believes it is a result of Cleopatra betraying him. Cleopatra runs to a mausoleum and locks herself in. There here servant Charmian tells Cleopatra that she should send a servant to tell Antony that she (Cleopatra) is dead, so she does. She then wants the servant to return to tell her how Antony took the news.
The clear implication is that Cleopatra is trying to see if Antony still loves her. She wants to know if he will mourn her or callously claim that he is relieved. Cleopatra's insecurity was previously seen when she was taken aback that Antony did not mourn more passionately for his wife Fulvia; she wonders if he will act the same when she herself dies.
The historical records we have, even those used by Shakespeare, do not make such a clear case for her wanting to test his love. Shakespeare's main source for the play was Plutarch's Life of Antony. Shakespeare's description of the death of Antony is very similar to the one in Plutarch. The main difference is that Plutarch does not make it clear that she is trying to test his love. In fact, Plutarch implies that she sends the message so that Antony, who believes he had been betrayed, will stop pursuing her. In other words, she is lying to him to save her own neck.
I think the notion that Cleopatra wants to see if Antony still loves her is mainly Shakespeare's idea, and I can't find it clearly stated as a motivation in any of the historical documents. On the other hand, it seems at least - which is why that is how I wrote it into the puppet show that I created to review this story.
As an interesting side note, almost all of the people who wrote a summary of the story of Antony and Cleopatra for the final included the detail that Cleopatra did it to test to see if Antony still loved her, even though I barely mentioned it in class. The puppet show seems to have been influential on how my students viewed the historical event. It is always best to look stuff up for yourself, and not to trust a puppet show too much.
Friday, June 3, 2016
Two new questions
Many students asked me personal questions. If you don't find these sorts of questions interesting, just drop me a message below.
What is your favorite dessert?
Probably brownies with dark chocolate chips. It really depends on my mood.
What is your favorite place that you have visited?
This is a hard question to answer. I teach and live in Mesa, so I travel during the summer when it is over 110 degrees much of the time. Any place that is cooler than here (almost anyplace) is a welcome break. I think, though, I will say Prince Edward Island. It has an interesting history, the people were nice, and the kids enjoyed it. We saw many of the sites relating to Anne of Green Gables, and it is interesting to see how people preserve the memory of Lucy Maude Montgomery. The air there smells great, it is cool, the prices are pretty reasonable in the summer (it is a winter vacation spot for many Canadians), and the temperatures were really nice for summer. Also, I was waiting to use a computer in the hotel lobby one evening and there was a group of high school students having a heated discussion of the Iiad. Apparently their public schools include a pretty strong classical element.
Another student asked a similar question, "What is your favorite place to visit?" The question is worded a little differently, and is easier for me to answer. My favorite place to visit is Los Alamos, where I grew up. Some people don't have an enormous affection for the place they are from, but I do. I dream of Los Alamos at night, and daydream of it in the day. I love the piƱon trees, the mountains and mesas, the cool evening breeze, the arroyos, the views, and the people. It is a bit disheartening to see how different it looks after the Sierra Grande fire, but I still love it there. My father lives there, and he is the nicest man I know. I have a lot of memories there, some of them quite poignant, but I do enjoy returning for a visit. As a resident of Mesa, I appreciate that it is considerably cooler there. I can remember it getting to 90 degrees there, but that is rare.
What is your favorite dessert?
Probably brownies with dark chocolate chips. It really depends on my mood.
What is your favorite place that you have visited?
This is a hard question to answer. I teach and live in Mesa, so I travel during the summer when it is over 110 degrees much of the time. Any place that is cooler than here (almost anyplace) is a welcome break. I think, though, I will say Prince Edward Island. It has an interesting history, the people were nice, and the kids enjoyed it. We saw many of the sites relating to Anne of Green Gables, and it is interesting to see how people preserve the memory of Lucy Maude Montgomery. The air there smells great, it is cool, the prices are pretty reasonable in the summer (it is a winter vacation spot for many Canadians), and the temperatures were really nice for summer. Also, I was waiting to use a computer in the hotel lobby one evening and there was a group of high school students having a heated discussion of the Iiad. Apparently their public schools include a pretty strong classical element.
Another student asked a similar question, "What is your favorite place to visit?" The question is worded a little differently, and is easier for me to answer. My favorite place to visit is Los Alamos, where I grew up. Some people don't have an enormous affection for the place they are from, but I do. I dream of Los Alamos at night, and daydream of it in the day. I love the piƱon trees, the mountains and mesas, the cool evening breeze, the arroyos, the views, and the people. It is a bit disheartening to see how different it looks after the Sierra Grande fire, but I still love it there. My father lives there, and he is the nicest man I know. I have a lot of memories there, some of them quite poignant, but I do enjoy returning for a visit. As a resident of Mesa, I appreciate that it is considerably cooler there. I can remember it getting to 90 degrees there, but that is rare.
Thursday, June 2, 2016
The Hardest Sport
What is the hardest sport?
I am glad that I got this question,
because it was the topic of discussion on Coast to Coast AM at
one point, and I did not like the reasoning the callers were using.
I can remember one guy said that it was baseball because of how hard
it is to hit something so small that is traveling so fast with a
little ashwood stick. I know that what he says is correct, as I saw
a show in which they were trying to make robots hit a baseball and it
was almost impossible. People are amazing, and it is good to reflect
a while on how many remarkable things you see every day without
thinking about it. That being said, a lot of people can hit a
baseball. I can hit a baseball, and I have hit baseballs that were
thrown by college players at high speeds, so it can't be the hardest
sport.
I have
two criteria for a sport being hard:
1.
Hundreds or thousands of people try to master the sport.
2.
Almost nobody does.
The
reason for the first criterion is that there are some sports that
only about eight people have tried. For a sport like that, maybe the
reason nobody really mastered it is that no skilled people have
dedicated adequate effort into trying. The reason for the second
criterion is obvious; if there is something that seems really hard if
you look at the physics of it, such as hitting a baseball, but
thousands of people can do it, then it can't be the hardest.
That
being said, I don't think you can say there is a hardest sport. In
this age of extreme sports, probably any athletic competition that
can done anywhere can be taken to an extreme level that only a
handful of people can compete at. Take holding your breath, for
example. Kids compete at it all the time. Probably anybody who has
access to a swimming pool has tried this sport at one time or
another. On the international level, though, there are very few
people who can hope to compete. Most people know about magician
David Blaine, who combined intense self-discipline and excessive
self-promotion to make himself famous by breaking the record for
extreme submerged breath holding (17 minutes and 4 seconds) – a
record that was broken by less well-known Stig Severinsen in 2012 (22
minutes).
Extreme
sports qualify for the title of “hardest sport” for the reasons I
gave, but also because you can die competing in them. In one famous
example, extreme diver Nicholas Mevoli died soon after a dive to a
depth of 236 feet.
Another
example of an extreme sport that many athletic and dedicated people
try is the ultramarathon. Perhaps the most grueling is the Badwater
Ultramarathon, which is 135 miles run in Death Valley in July. I
live in Mesa, AZ – which is HOT, but not as hot as Death Valley –
and it is hard for me to imagine running water, much less running a
race, in July. Everyone who competes in this race is an
ultramarathoner who has trained years in various extreme conditions,
but very few people complete the race. I know sometimes baseball
players can't finish a game, but it would be an entirely different
sport if almost the entire team didn't make it through the ninth
inning.
Wednesday, June 1, 2016
Armenian Genocide
I recently asked my students to ask me a question for my blog as
part of their final. I received well over 100 new questions!
I do not have over 100 students; many students asked several
questions. I had originally intended to cull the most
interesting questions to answer and dispense of the rest, but now I
have decided to answer the questions at the rate of about one per day
until I lose energy.
Today's question: What do you know about the Armenian Genocide?
Among scholars of modern history, the Armenian Genocide is widely studied and discussed. It is not well-known among non-scholars, and most of my students say they have never heard the phrase "Armenian Genocide."
The modern country of Armenia is located in Western Asia, bordering Turkey, Iran, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Nagorno-Karabakh Republic, and Nakhchivan. Although occupying a small territory, Armenia has had an immense influence on the history of the world. Although the Persian Empire was centered in Persia (Iran), it had its roots in Armenia, as did the Persian Zoroastrian religion – which is regarded as the first world religion because it was spread through Western Asia and Eastern Europe by the Persians.
Armenia is predominately Christian, and it was the first kingdom to adopt Christianity as its official religion in 301 CE. In fact, the Armenians' tenacious adherence to Christianity is connected to much of the persecution they have suffered throughout the ages. As Islam spread through Eastern Europe and Western Asia, traditionally Christian ethnic groups like the Armenians and Assyrians have been persecuted, dislocated, and virtually exterminated.
For the most part, the Armenian Genocide did not occur where the modern day country of Armenia is, but where Turkey is now located. By the 1800s, there were large communities of Armenians living in Constantinople (now known as Istanbul) and in the Eastern region of the Ottoman Empire. These Armenians had been there for centuries at this time, and the Ottoman Empire largely tolerated them. There were limits on their right to travel, to do business, and there were special taxes, but the Armenians mostly kept to the regions that they had traditionally held and everybody was happy.
This changed in the 1890s. The Ottoman Empire started to crumble, and Sultan Abdul Hamid II blamed this on Christians within the empire, saying that Christians were likely to prefer being ruled by Russia and they couldn't be trusted. At first he merely cracked down on their travel and trade, but eventually authorized the military to kill as many Armenians as they could. Nobody knows how many were killed at this time, but it amounts to hundreds of thousands.
This was definitely a hard time for Armenians, but it got worse. In the early 20th century, the Young Turk revolution replaced the totalitarian monarchy with a constitutional democracy. At first, the Armenians welcomed this change because they saw in it the possibility that they would be able to have a voice in the government. In fact, the Young Turks were the worst thing that happened to the Armenians.
The Young Turks believed that Turkey should be for the Turks, and not for non-Turkish, non-Muslim people like the Armenians. Even though the Armenians had been living in their territories for centuries upon centuries, the Young Turks viewed them as foreigners who did not belong.
During World War I, the Ottomans made an alliance with the Germans and joined the Central Powers. Many Ottomans suspected that the Armenians would be disloyal, so they called for removing Armenians from the military. Also, the Ottomans began removing various Christian groups from their ancestral lands, arguing that their loyalty could not be trusted.
Until this point, most Armenians had loyally served the Ottomans militarily, but now that their loyalty was being questioned and many non-Armenians were being killed, many of them teamed up with Russia to oppose the Ottomans. The Russian Empire, which was Christian, was seen by many Armenians as their best hope for liberation.
On April 24, 1915, the Ottomans officially began their attempt to “cleanse” their lands of the Armenians. They forcibly removed them from their homes and forced them to march through the desert to concentration camps. Many of them died in the intense heat. People who stopped were shot on the spot. Bands of thugs went through the neighborhoods of Armenians and other Christians, killing the adults and taking the children to be raised by Turks. The genocide lasted until the end of World War I.
By the end of the war, an estimated 1.5 million Armenians had been killed in massacres, worked to death in concentration camps, or marched to death in the desert. To put that number in perspective, it is almost exactly the population of Phoenix. Next time you are driving through Phoenix, look around and imagine what it would mean if every person you see – every old man, every baby, every teenager – were brutally murdered. Really, do it. This is as close as you can come to imagining the horror of this event.
The Turkish government still resists referring to this mass killing of Armenians as “genocide.”
Today's question: What do you know about the Armenian Genocide?
Among scholars of modern history, the Armenian Genocide is widely studied and discussed. It is not well-known among non-scholars, and most of my students say they have never heard the phrase "Armenian Genocide."
The modern country of Armenia is located in Western Asia, bordering Turkey, Iran, Azerbaijan, Georgia, Nagorno-Karabakh Republic, and Nakhchivan. Although occupying a small territory, Armenia has had an immense influence on the history of the world. Although the Persian Empire was centered in Persia (Iran), it had its roots in Armenia, as did the Persian Zoroastrian religion – which is regarded as the first world religion because it was spread through Western Asia and Eastern Europe by the Persians.
Armenia is predominately Christian, and it was the first kingdom to adopt Christianity as its official religion in 301 CE. In fact, the Armenians' tenacious adherence to Christianity is connected to much of the persecution they have suffered throughout the ages. As Islam spread through Eastern Europe and Western Asia, traditionally Christian ethnic groups like the Armenians and Assyrians have been persecuted, dislocated, and virtually exterminated.
For the most part, the Armenian Genocide did not occur where the modern day country of Armenia is, but where Turkey is now located. By the 1800s, there were large communities of Armenians living in Constantinople (now known as Istanbul) and in the Eastern region of the Ottoman Empire. These Armenians had been there for centuries at this time, and the Ottoman Empire largely tolerated them. There were limits on their right to travel, to do business, and there were special taxes, but the Armenians mostly kept to the regions that they had traditionally held and everybody was happy.
This changed in the 1890s. The Ottoman Empire started to crumble, and Sultan Abdul Hamid II blamed this on Christians within the empire, saying that Christians were likely to prefer being ruled by Russia and they couldn't be trusted. At first he merely cracked down on their travel and trade, but eventually authorized the military to kill as many Armenians as they could. Nobody knows how many were killed at this time, but it amounts to hundreds of thousands.
This was definitely a hard time for Armenians, but it got worse. In the early 20th century, the Young Turk revolution replaced the totalitarian monarchy with a constitutional democracy. At first, the Armenians welcomed this change because they saw in it the possibility that they would be able to have a voice in the government. In fact, the Young Turks were the worst thing that happened to the Armenians.
The Young Turks believed that Turkey should be for the Turks, and not for non-Turkish, non-Muslim people like the Armenians. Even though the Armenians had been living in their territories for centuries upon centuries, the Young Turks viewed them as foreigners who did not belong.
During World War I, the Ottomans made an alliance with the Germans and joined the Central Powers. Many Ottomans suspected that the Armenians would be disloyal, so they called for removing Armenians from the military. Also, the Ottomans began removing various Christian groups from their ancestral lands, arguing that their loyalty could not be trusted.
Until this point, most Armenians had loyally served the Ottomans militarily, but now that their loyalty was being questioned and many non-Armenians were being killed, many of them teamed up with Russia to oppose the Ottomans. The Russian Empire, which was Christian, was seen by many Armenians as their best hope for liberation.
On April 24, 1915, the Ottomans officially began their attempt to “cleanse” their lands of the Armenians. They forcibly removed them from their homes and forced them to march through the desert to concentration camps. Many of them died in the intense heat. People who stopped were shot on the spot. Bands of thugs went through the neighborhoods of Armenians and other Christians, killing the adults and taking the children to be raised by Turks. The genocide lasted until the end of World War I.
By the end of the war, an estimated 1.5 million Armenians had been killed in massacres, worked to death in concentration camps, or marched to death in the desert. To put that number in perspective, it is almost exactly the population of Phoenix. Next time you are driving through Phoenix, look around and imagine what it would mean if every person you see – every old man, every baby, every teenager – were brutally murdered. Really, do it. This is as close as you can come to imagining the horror of this event.
The Turkish government still resists referring to this mass killing of Armenians as “genocide.”
Monday, May 23, 2016
Jeopardy Games
Here are the links to the three Jeopardy games we played in class today.
8th Grade
Florentine Renaissance Jeopardy
7th Grade
Roman Empire
8th Grade
Florentine Renaissance Jeopardy
Florentine Renaissance Double Jeopardy
7th Grade
Roman Empire
Monday, April 11, 2016
Wednesday, February 10, 2016
Monday, April 27, 2015
Theft in Rome
Question: What was the punishment for stealing something in ancient Rome?
Roman law, including the laws for theft ("furtum"), changed quite a bit over the course of history. Under the oldest known law code, the Twelve Tables, the laws differed somewhat depending on whether the person was a slave or a free man. A free man was generally flogged and given into slavery to the person whose property he took, while a slave would be beaten then executed. If you were to be caught stealing at night and killed, the killer would not be punished. If it was during the day, then you were allowed to try to physically stop the thief, but you were allowed to kill that person only if he try to defend himself.
What eventually developed in Roman law was a distinction between criminal and civil law. If someone's property were taken, the state would issue a punishment and the person could bring a lawsuit against the thief. In the case of a slave or non-citizen, it seems that flogging and execution were still common punishments, while most citizens could expect to repay the victim for the stolen item two to four times its original value. The thief also might be sued, particularly if the victim could show that the item is irreplaceable or that not having for a time caused damage (such as a plow that was stolen during harvest).
It is easy to see that Roman law provided the basis for our laws, which also depend on civil and criminal penalties. Roman law also tended to be somewhat flexible, and the penalties were decided on a case-by-case basis - although the court always needed to point to a precedent in which a similar case was decided in the same way.
Roman law, including the laws for theft ("furtum"), changed quite a bit over the course of history. Under the oldest known law code, the Twelve Tables, the laws differed somewhat depending on whether the person was a slave or a free man. A free man was generally flogged and given into slavery to the person whose property he took, while a slave would be beaten then executed. If you were to be caught stealing at night and killed, the killer would not be punished. If it was during the day, then you were allowed to try to physically stop the thief, but you were allowed to kill that person only if he try to defend himself.
What eventually developed in Roman law was a distinction between criminal and civil law. If someone's property were taken, the state would issue a punishment and the person could bring a lawsuit against the thief. In the case of a slave or non-citizen, it seems that flogging and execution were still common punishments, while most citizens could expect to repay the victim for the stolen item two to four times its original value. The thief also might be sued, particularly if the victim could show that the item is irreplaceable or that not having for a time caused damage (such as a plow that was stolen during harvest).
It is easy to see that Roman law provided the basis for our laws, which also depend on civil and criminal penalties. Roman law also tended to be somewhat flexible, and the penalties were decided on a case-by-case basis - although the court always needed to point to a precedent in which a similar case was decided in the same way.
Tuesday, June 25, 2013
Marionettes
Question: How did marionettes get their name?
Although Asia has traditions of puppetry that may go back thousands of years, it seems that puppetry as we know it in the West is a relatively recent phenomenon that we can trace back about 500 years. This is not to say that nobody had any sort of puppets before the 16th century -- using dolls or stuffed animals to tell stories seems like an obvious activity -- but we don't have much historical information about these local folk traditions. Puppetry seems to have become a widespread cultural phenomenon quite quickly, spreading from the cultural centers of Europe, particularly France. While most folk puppets were dolls on sticks, French puppet masters promoted the use of wooden puppets with articulated joints, which became the predecessors of our marionettes.
As is the case today, puppets were seen as both a way to entertain and educate. Roman Catholic leaders were particularly interested in using them to educate the masses, many of whom were illiterate, about religious stories and theological concepts. This was tied to a movement we now call the "Counter-Reformation," which emphasized the need to educate all believers in proper doctrine. It seems that the most common type of puppet show taught about the inevitability of death and the need to resist temptation, and the puppet shows were essentially performed versions of the danse macabre, which we discussed in class.
Other shows, though, taught theological concepts such as redemption and virgin birth. Puppets representing Mary were common enough that the term "marionette," which is derived from French and means "little Mary," became the generic term for puppets suspended from string. Since puppetry itself was spread from France, it is not surprising that the term "puppet" also has a French derivation. "Popee" means "doll," and so "puppet" means "little doll."
Although Asia has traditions of puppetry that may go back thousands of years, it seems that puppetry as we know it in the West is a relatively recent phenomenon that we can trace back about 500 years. This is not to say that nobody had any sort of puppets before the 16th century -- using dolls or stuffed animals to tell stories seems like an obvious activity -- but we don't have much historical information about these local folk traditions. Puppetry seems to have become a widespread cultural phenomenon quite quickly, spreading from the cultural centers of Europe, particularly France. While most folk puppets were dolls on sticks, French puppet masters promoted the use of wooden puppets with articulated joints, which became the predecessors of our marionettes.
As is the case today, puppets were seen as both a way to entertain and educate. Roman Catholic leaders were particularly interested in using them to educate the masses, many of whom were illiterate, about religious stories and theological concepts. This was tied to a movement we now call the "Counter-Reformation," which emphasized the need to educate all believers in proper doctrine. It seems that the most common type of puppet show taught about the inevitability of death and the need to resist temptation, and the puppet shows were essentially performed versions of the danse macabre, which we discussed in class.
Other shows, though, taught theological concepts such as redemption and virgin birth. Puppets representing Mary were common enough that the term "marionette," which is derived from French and means "little Mary," became the generic term for puppets suspended from string. Since puppetry itself was spread from France, it is not surprising that the term "puppet" also has a French derivation. "Popee" means "doll," and so "puppet" means "little doll."
Tuesday, June 18, 2013
Money
Question: Who came up with the idea of money?
The Greeks believed that money originated in Lydia, an ancient kingdom of Asia Minor, and it does seem likely that coinage in the West originates with silver coins minted in Lydia in the sixth century BCE. By this time, though, the Chinese had already been using coins for about 500 years. The Chinese had long used cowrie shells as a type of currency, and it seems that the first coins were in the shape of these shells. The Chinese also used other valuable items as "trade markers," and they made replicas of these before they developed the idea of round coins. Throughout Chinese history, coins typically had holes in the middle so that they could be held on a string.
In the East, coins tended to be made of base metals, and the value of the coins was not completely tied to the value of the metal that makes up the coins. In the West, early coins were essentially developed as a convenient means of determining how much of a valuable metal you actually had. The early Lydian coins were made of silver, which was a metal that had long been used for trade. The coins were standard sizes and were stamped with the insignia of the issuing authority, originally the King of Lydia. If you trusted the king and were sure that you did not have a counterfeit, then you would not have to weigh the silver you received in payment, which was useful because people often argued over the accuracy of various scales. Some coins were even made in a such a way that they could be divided into pieces if you were buying something at discount; our terms "pieces of eight" and "two bits" originate from this practice.
Another question is suggested by all this: When did people decide that the value of money should not be based on the value of the metal but on some other, less tangible, value? This is something that took longer than you might expect, particularly in the West. Today, all major, international currencies are what we call "fiat currencies." A US dollar, for example, is not worth a dollar because it is made of something valuable, but because the US government says it is worth a dollar. As long as people trust that other people will continue to value the currency, then they will use them and accept them as payment.
When I was born, the currency was still "tied to" gold. In other words, each dollar bill presumably had the same value as a dollar gold coin, and each dollar was supposed to correspond to some amount of gold held by the United States. In other words, the dollar bills were essentially representations of actual gold currency. Of course, the US did not have gold backing up all the money, which is essentially what is meant by "inflation" - an increase in the amount of currency available resulting in the lowering of value of the currency. In 1971, the US gave up the pretext of backing money using gold.
In the East, a pure fiat currency was instituted in the 11th century CE. Why wasn't the original coin currency of China considered a fiat currency? It seems that historical economists don't consider it a fiat currency because the coins were thought to have some intrinsic value, although their value as currency was not limited entirely to this value.
As archaeologists continue to explore ancient sites, it seems likely that they will find that the idea of currency arose slowly rather than being developed all at once. For example, there are prehistoric carved obsidian objects found in sites in Asia Minor that may have been used as coins. They are typically found in collections near places of trade, and analysis does not indicate that they had been used for any practical purposes. It seems that they were likely first used to keep track of trades, and that the notion of using them as a means of purchase developed from that.
Write me a note to let me know if I answered your question.
The Greeks believed that money originated in Lydia, an ancient kingdom of Asia Minor, and it does seem likely that coinage in the West originates with silver coins minted in Lydia in the sixth century BCE. By this time, though, the Chinese had already been using coins for about 500 years. The Chinese had long used cowrie shells as a type of currency, and it seems that the first coins were in the shape of these shells. The Chinese also used other valuable items as "trade markers," and they made replicas of these before they developed the idea of round coins. Throughout Chinese history, coins typically had holes in the middle so that they could be held on a string.
In the East, coins tended to be made of base metals, and the value of the coins was not completely tied to the value of the metal that makes up the coins. In the West, early coins were essentially developed as a convenient means of determining how much of a valuable metal you actually had. The early Lydian coins were made of silver, which was a metal that had long been used for trade. The coins were standard sizes and were stamped with the insignia of the issuing authority, originally the King of Lydia. If you trusted the king and were sure that you did not have a counterfeit, then you would not have to weigh the silver you received in payment, which was useful because people often argued over the accuracy of various scales. Some coins were even made in a such a way that they could be divided into pieces if you were buying something at discount; our terms "pieces of eight" and "two bits" originate from this practice.
Another question is suggested by all this: When did people decide that the value of money should not be based on the value of the metal but on some other, less tangible, value? This is something that took longer than you might expect, particularly in the West. Today, all major, international currencies are what we call "fiat currencies." A US dollar, for example, is not worth a dollar because it is made of something valuable, but because the US government says it is worth a dollar. As long as people trust that other people will continue to value the currency, then they will use them and accept them as payment.
When I was born, the currency was still "tied to" gold. In other words, each dollar bill presumably had the same value as a dollar gold coin, and each dollar was supposed to correspond to some amount of gold held by the United States. In other words, the dollar bills were essentially representations of actual gold currency. Of course, the US did not have gold backing up all the money, which is essentially what is meant by "inflation" - an increase in the amount of currency available resulting in the lowering of value of the currency. In 1971, the US gave up the pretext of backing money using gold.
In the East, a pure fiat currency was instituted in the 11th century CE. Why wasn't the original coin currency of China considered a fiat currency? It seems that historical economists don't consider it a fiat currency because the coins were thought to have some intrinsic value, although their value as currency was not limited entirely to this value.
As archaeologists continue to explore ancient sites, it seems likely that they will find that the idea of currency arose slowly rather than being developed all at once. For example, there are prehistoric carved obsidian objects found in sites in Asia Minor that may have been used as coins. They are typically found in collections near places of trade, and analysis does not indicate that they had been used for any practical purposes. It seems that they were likely first used to keep track of trades, and that the notion of using them as a means of purchase developed from that.
Write me a note to let me know if I answered your question.
Thursday, June 13, 2013
Triton
Question: Did Triton have a Roman form?
Triton is a Greek god that was also worshiped by the Romans under the same name. Triton is typically shown with a fish tail, and he oversaw some sea people known as "Tritons," which were essentially merpeople. Other cultures have some form of merpeople, but Greek Tritons are clearly one of the main sources for myths of fish-tailed humans living in the depths of the oceans. It seems that Triton was once the god of the sea in some regions of Greece. As worship of Poseidon became dominant, mythology transformed Triton from being a rival god to being a son of Poseidon. Triton looks really cool, and he was a frequent subject of Renaissance sculpture, particularly in Italy.
Triton is a Greek god that was also worshiped by the Romans under the same name. Triton is typically shown with a fish tail, and he oversaw some sea people known as "Tritons," which were essentially merpeople. Other cultures have some form of merpeople, but Greek Tritons are clearly one of the main sources for myths of fish-tailed humans living in the depths of the oceans. It seems that Triton was once the god of the sea in some regions of Greece. As worship of Poseidon became dominant, mythology transformed Triton from being a rival god to being a son of Poseidon. Triton looks really cool, and he was a frequent subject of Renaissance sculpture, particularly in Italy.
Emperor in the US
Question: Do you think that a Roman-like emperor could ever take over the United States?
It does seem that republics have a limited lifespan. After the Roman Republic, there were several Italian city-states that existed as republics (Florence, Pisa, Verona, etc.), but none of them lasted forever. In the past 200 years, we have seen nations in all the continents start to shift towards some sort of representative democracy. People today, particularly in the West, tend to see this as a natural progression, and that some sort of representative democracy will be the dominant political mode of the future. The problem with this assessment is that none of these republics has lasted very long so far. Regardless of what date you give to the founding of the republic (the signing of the Articles of Confederation? The Declaration of Independence? The Constitution?), we can safely say that United States is less than 250 years old. This is roughly half the age that the Roman Republic was when it started to be replaced by the Roman Empire. It is possible that one day in the future people will look back at this era as representing a failed experiment carried out by nations around the world.
This raises a question, What might happen to bring about the end of the American Republic? Many writers and political philosophers have looked for parallels between the United States and the Roman Republic, and there are hundreds of different opinions about what elements in our country resemble those that led to the beginning of the Roman Empire. It is hard to pinpoint a single cause for the end of the Roman Republic because there was so much going on, but the following are contributing factors:
It does seem that republics have a limited lifespan. After the Roman Republic, there were several Italian city-states that existed as republics (Florence, Pisa, Verona, etc.), but none of them lasted forever. In the past 200 years, we have seen nations in all the continents start to shift towards some sort of representative democracy. People today, particularly in the West, tend to see this as a natural progression, and that some sort of representative democracy will be the dominant political mode of the future. The problem with this assessment is that none of these republics has lasted very long so far. Regardless of what date you give to the founding of the republic (the signing of the Articles of Confederation? The Declaration of Independence? The Constitution?), we can safely say that United States is less than 250 years old. This is roughly half the age that the Roman Republic was when it started to be replaced by the Roman Empire. It is possible that one day in the future people will look back at this era as representing a failed experiment carried out by nations around the world.
This raises a question, What might happen to bring about the end of the American Republic? Many writers and political philosophers have looked for parallels between the United States and the Roman Republic, and there are hundreds of different opinions about what elements in our country resemble those that led to the beginning of the Roman Empire. It is hard to pinpoint a single cause for the end of the Roman Republic because there was so much going on, but the following are contributing factors:
- The Republic depended on constant military expansion to acquire land,
- Rome conquered many regions where Roman power was resented,
- Roman citizens, particularly in the city of Rome itself, resented giving any amount of control to conquered people and immigrants,
- There was a strain on the food supply that was caused by many different factors, including drought and farming practices that depleted the soil,
- The strain between the classes, which had always been a feature of the Republic, became increasingly dangerous after the Marian Reforms, because military service was expanded to include people who did not have any property. This opened the door for people who saw the military as an opportunity to gain property, which was typically given out by the generals after successful campaigns. These new soldiers tended to see their generals themselves as their benefactors; they became more loyal to their military leaders than to the state of Rome. This is what allowed Sulla to march against Rome, and was an essential element in the rise of Julius Caesar and Augustus.
In the end, it seems the deciding factor is that people stopped being loyal to Rome, but instead focused on their families, classes, centuries, generals, and so on. In other words, Rome became factionalized. Whenever there was a need for austerity, everybody thought it was somebody else's job to be make the sacrifices. In the early days of our republic, people were very aware that the Roman Republic had failed, and many people thought this was reason enough not to try such a radical form of representative democracy. In response, the founders of our republic decided that they would mitigate the threat of factions by making political parties illegal, thinking that this would prevent one type of factionalism that was already problematic in the English Parliament. The Federalist Papers, many of which you will read in ninth grade, make the argument that having divided loyalties will naturally lead to the downfall of the republic; these essays argue for a strong central government which will counterbalance the tendency towards loyalty to factions based on party, state, class, region, etc. The Federalist Papers hold that there is always a sense in which people must give up some of their self-interest in service of the state, and that the unwillingness to do so will lead to the end of the republic.
In Democracy in America, Alexis de Tocqueville makes a similar argument. While he realizes that political parties are a "necessary evil" (a phrase he actually uses), Tocqueville argues that "great political parties" are those that "cling to principles," while more destructive political parties "display the selfishness of their characters in their actions." About 30 years after Tocqueville wrote, the country did become divided, the southern faction warring against the northern. As the country underwent change and turmoil, people allowed regional loyalties to overtake their commitment to the commonwealth.
I think the danger of factionalism is also demonstrated by the political activity the seventh graders did in the last quarter of ancient history class. 7C was much more successful at forming a government, mostly because the students were dedicated to the idea of making it work. In 7A, the students were so worried about people watching out for their own friends that very few were really willing to commit to the activity. For an undertaking like that to work, the participants must have some amount of belief in the "rightness" of the activity. Without that, the only way to assure participation is to find some way to force students to take part, which is very hard to do, and it would not teach the appropriate lesson.
The worry that I have about the US is that people have widely differing ideas about the purpose of a nation. People on the Libertarian end of the spectrum see the role limited largely to national defense, while more socially-minded people think that the government should have a role in providing health care, a social safety net, cultural enrichment, and so on. I don't want to get into an argument about whose view is "right." I think either approach has its advantages and disadvantages. I also tend to think that people have different dispositions, and many of their beliefs about the proper role of government arises from this. Arguing about what form of government the Founding Fathers wanted seems to miss the point; what we really need to do is to talk openly about what sort of government we want, since we are the people using.
What I am worried about is that people get so caught up in their own vision of how the country should work is that they give up on the notion of service and self-sacrifice that makes it work. Although some people, such as Ayn Rand, believe that the best economic and political systems are based on self-interest, I don't see that history supports this. The times when our country worked best were times when people surrendered some of their self-interest for a common goal. While I fear collectivism and see the danger of blind patriotism (look at North Korea), I don't know of any country that thrived without some sense of unity among its people. I think we are at a crisis now because we are divided about who we are and what the our purposes should be. It is possible that war could give us that sense, but I wish that we could focus on a more humane purpose than killing other people.
Another factor that seems to point to the possibility of an emperor is economic inequality. Americans love the rich, largely because so many believe that one day they will be rich, too. This becomes clear when people are debating things like the estate tax, which affects only quite wealthy people. Americans tend to think that, although they wouldn't have to pay it if they died now, by the time they actually get around to dying they probably will be that rich. I do think, though, that this attitude could change. Think of all the talk of the "1%" in the most recent presidential election. If people start to think of themselves as somehow permanently disenfranchised, somebody akin to the Gracchus brothers might seize the opportunity to shake up the established order.
That being said, I doubt that a single emperor will ever rule over the entire US. I think that the country would fracture first, and that various sorts of rulers would arise in various regions. The only reason the Roman people supported the emperors is that they thought it was in their own best interest to do so; most Romans were better off under the Roman Empire. I doubt one person could convince enough people that the whole nation would turn over control to him/her.
Let me know what you think by posting a comment.
Wednesday, June 5, 2013
Disneyland
Question: What is your favorite Disneyland ride (I'm guessing it is Indiana Jones)?
I have never been on the Indiana Jones ride. I have been on most rides, but the line was long and the kids were not enthusiastic about having things flying at them, so we skipped that one. The rides I like best are the ones that have some fantasy element. I enjoy the experience of being taken out of the ordinary world for a while. My favorite rides are the Haunted House and Pirates of the Caribbean. I don't really like the changes they made to both of these rides, but they are not horrible, either. I like things that are kind of creepy and macabre, but also whimsical. This is why I think Johnny Depp was a good choice to star in the Pirates of the Caribbean movies. I have only seen one of these movies, and thought the plot was rather boring, but I thought Johnny Depp was good. I have a theory that he is a relatively normal guy who has cultivated sort of a creepy persona for commercial benefit, but I could be wrong.
I don't know about you, but the more I know about how the rides are designed and how the illusions work the more magical I find them. If that describes you, check out www.doombuggies.com.
The scariest ride I went on there was the Ferris Wheel at California Adventure. It was scarier than the Tower of Terror to me. I think because it was easy to see how the thing worked so that it was easy to imagine it failing to work. I talked to some people who will not go on roller coasters, but who find the Ferris Wheel to be fun. Not me. I have never been on a roller coaster that left as terrified as the Ferris Wheel. Also, I find the roller coaster at Schnepf farms to be scarier than any of the big ones because it seems like something that a guy put together in his garage. It also jars my spine, and so I may not ever ride it again.
If there is anybody still reading this, add a comment. I have a big collection of questions, but don't want to work on it all summer if I am the only person who is going to read it.
I have never been on the Indiana Jones ride. I have been on most rides, but the line was long and the kids were not enthusiastic about having things flying at them, so we skipped that one. The rides I like best are the ones that have some fantasy element. I enjoy the experience of being taken out of the ordinary world for a while. My favorite rides are the Haunted House and Pirates of the Caribbean. I don't really like the changes they made to both of these rides, but they are not horrible, either. I like things that are kind of creepy and macabre, but also whimsical. This is why I think Johnny Depp was a good choice to star in the Pirates of the Caribbean movies. I have only seen one of these movies, and thought the plot was rather boring, but I thought Johnny Depp was good. I have a theory that he is a relatively normal guy who has cultivated sort of a creepy persona for commercial benefit, but I could be wrong.
I don't know about you, but the more I know about how the rides are designed and how the illusions work the more magical I find them. If that describes you, check out www.doombuggies.com.
The scariest ride I went on there was the Ferris Wheel at California Adventure. It was scarier than the Tower of Terror to me. I think because it was easy to see how the thing worked so that it was easy to imagine it failing to work. I talked to some people who will not go on roller coasters, but who find the Ferris Wheel to be fun. Not me. I have never been on a roller coaster that left as terrified as the Ferris Wheel. Also, I find the roller coaster at Schnepf farms to be scarier than any of the big ones because it seems like something that a guy put together in his garage. It also jars my spine, and so I may not ever ride it again.
If there is anybody still reading this, add a comment. I have a big collection of questions, but don't want to work on it all summer if I am the only person who is going to read it.
Monday, June 3, 2013
Underdog
An eighth grader asked why we root for the underdog in our society, while other cultures do not have a bias towards the underdog. This question reminded me of an excellent radio show I heard on just this topic. Click here to go to the show's webpage, then click on "listen." It is such a great show that I am not even going to try to answer the question myself.
Real Numbers
I received quite a few questions, including some very reflective and cerebral ones. Since I am a teacher, and I sometimes need to be circumspect to avoid offending people, I will let my friend Anjo answer the questions that delve into the dangerous areas of religion and philosophy.
Question #1. Why are are numbers real numbers, even the imaginary ones?
A real number is a number that exists on the number line. It includes positive numbers, negative number and irrational numbers. An irrational number is essentially a number that cannot be expressed as a simple ratio. The best-known irrational number is pi, which also called a "transcendental number" because it cannot be expressed as the result of a mathematical formula. This reminds me of a frustrating story that conveys an important life lesson. My eighth-grade math teacher was named Mrs. Brownell. She taught us that if we were calculating using pi, we could use 3.14 if we wanted, but if we wanted to be absolutely accurate we should convert our decimals to fractions and use 22/7 for pi. She said that 22/7 was pi exactly. A student pointed out that mathematicians try to calculate pi out to more and more decimal places. Mrs. Brownell said that they do this by dividing 22 by 7 and carrying it out to more and more decimal places. I figured that this is something that even I could do, so I did the division and soon realized that the number I got was both different than the standard expression of pi (starting in the thousandths place) and started to repeat (which everybody knows pi does not do). I told Mrs. Brownell who said that I must have divided wrong. I asked her to try it on the board to show me, but she got angry and said it was a waste of time to teach me how to divide in 8th grade. I redid my calculations and showed it to her. She refused to look at it and told me that I should probably argue with her husband, who is a mathematician at Los Alamos lab. The bell rang and she stormed out of the class. Instead of looking at my calculation, she became defensive and angry. The moral of the story is that children are expected to question assumptions unless those assumptions are made by people in authority. Also, adults tend to dig themselves into incredible intellectual ruts - try your best not to that. I realize that teachers are the worst, because we want everything we say to be authoritative, and we don't like to analyze our own assumptions.
Back to the number. Pi is considered a real number because it sits somewhere on the number line. While nobody knows pi in its entirety, we know that it sits on the number line between 3 and 4 (closer to 3), and it can be used like a regular number. The square root of 2, likewise, is an irrational number because it can't be expressed as a ratio, but we know it is sitting there somewhere.
Imaginary numbers are something else, and they are NOT real numbers. The term "imaginary" was invented to distinguish it from real numbers. The problem that they address is that negative numbers cannot have a square root, because any number multiplied by itself yields a positive result (a negative number multiplied by a positive number shows that you have a certain number of that negative number, so the solution is always negative). In some cases you want to know what the square root of a number would be if it were not impossible to have one, so they came up with imaginary numbers. Imaginary numbers yield a negative result when multiplied by themselves. They are mathematically useful when you are dealing with things like non-linear forecasting or calculating impedance. More on this later.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
